Rabbi R' Shloime Tirer - R' Shloime Tirer רבי שלמה טירער (טירר)

Started by Private User on Sunday, April 26, 2020
Problem with this page?

Participants:

  • Private User
    Geni member

Related Projects:

Showing all 2 posts

According to Shmuel meir Hollander R Shlomo was a son of Rabbi Raphael Meisels, Author of Tosfot Shabbat , although according to newer sources he was a grandchild of his.

תו החיים' נספח לשער התפילה תשכ"ט'

תהילים תהילה לדוד' אברהם דוד, ירושלים תשל"ד, בראש הספר'.

מאורי גליציה על חיים טירר

On Geni his father is called Rafael son of Chaim, and Chaim the son of the Tosfos shabbos was still alive when Shlomo's son was born, and one doesn't give names after those that are still alive.
Also he wasn't from R' Alexander, the year wouldn't make sense.
From the daughter on Gutvirth cannot be since her husband was a Cohen and R Shlomo Tirer was certainly not.

If one would say that the profile of this persons father is right and not actually meant to be the Tosfot Shabbat who was called Rafael the son of Chaim, (if is is then it should be moved a generation), but if it right that the father was called Rafael and was not the Tosfot Shabbat then he was probably the son of R Moshe:
Who has a son on Geni called Rafael Raphael Meislish

And then the profile of Rafael's father "Chaim" is a mix-up with the Tosfos Shabbat's father.

Meaning that according to these sources what is written in Geni is wrong.

I merged Rafael into the most likely candidate, (the son of R Moshe) whoever has more information should please contact me.

Of course any curator that thinks it was a wrong move can undo this merge (it is just one merged profile so not very difficult).

Showing all 2 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion