Harmon Back, Jr - Not the son of Hermann Bach and Anna Margaretha Hausemann

I am trusting the research of the direct descendants.
Per the FAG with notes and reference to the DAR record which has been updated this summer---

I am seeing two men.
One married Margaret Margaret Martha Back
One married Katherine “Catrin” Bach

Harman Back, Jr. and Harman Back, Jr. are not the same.

One of them will NEED to be DISCONNECTED from parents as both are claiming Hermann Bach and Anna Margarethe Bach

Barbara Price, A509195

This is such a delicate subject, I don't want to offend anyone!!!

I can tell you that Harman Back, Jr. was not born in Germany in 1737. The only birth record for a child of Hermannus/Hermann/Harman Bach/Back is the 1737 birth and baptism record for their daughter Anna Ella. She does not have a twin, she does not have a brother and there is no other child born to the couple while in Germany. I've searched the church books in both Freudenberg and Oberfischbach from 1737 to 1740, and there is no other child for them. There also is no death record for Anna Ella, she did not die in her village in Germany. Dr. Holtzclaw states in Germanna Record No. 5 that there is no further information for Anna Ella, which means he could find no records pertaining to her in the US, not surprising as this is the plight of women!

Even the note made in the Death Register in Freudenberg by the pastor notes only "1 Kindt," 1 child, not two, and that one child would be Anna Ella.

It's always good to go back to the original sources, if we can find them and that's what I did with the Bach and allied families. I had several records for them anyway as I'm gathering records for each of the immigrants, but didn't have the birth/baptism record of Anna Ella. I'm glad that I was able to find it!

If we keep Harman Back, Jr. as the son of Hermannus and Anna Margaretha (Hausmann) Bach, then there are corrections that need to be made to the Profile which I am happy to do.

When Cathi and I are in Virginia in November, we will go through all of the tax records, land records, anything that we can find to help sort out these families.

Barb

At this time, I would disconnect Harman BACK, Jr. from Hermannus Bach and Anna Margaretha Hausmann and keep Harman BACH, Jr. as their son.

Barb

Disconnecting Harman Back, Jr.

Keeping Harman Back, Jr.

Wait--- https://media.geni.com/p14/5e/3b/05/f1/534448614be6a256/534448614be...

https://services.dar.org/Public/DAR_Research/search_adb/?action=ful...

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/195090841/harman-back
Faustine Darsey on hiatus

Who is DAR saying is correct?
I can't find which I put the letter

Let me make sure I understand:
Per DAR, Joseph Back, of Garrard County is the son of Harman Back, Jr. and Harman Back, Jr. is the DAR accepted son of Hermann Bach and Anna Margarethe Bach ?

Henry Back, of Madison County and John Back, of Madison County are disconnected from Hermann Bach based on the DAR approved genealogy

https://media.geni.com/p13/6f/90/1f/9c/5344485ef9ebd771/win53hut_or... is Katherine “Catrin” Bach and Harman Back, Jr.

I had the document on the wrong profile lol (Katherine Fishback)
It is moved now.

I want to be clear when we disconnect a son Jr

I think I moved Joseph over the week-end?
I think the Germanna genealogists are in agreement over a will naming him being on the wrong one and it has been corrected from my understanding

Now is the problem of disconnecting.
Would be easier if they were the same man

Yes, we Genealogists at the Germanna Foundation are in agreement with you, Cynthia!

When Cathi and I are in Virginia in November, we will do some very in depth research concerning the Bach family. I will have my list for sure!!!

Barb

https://www.geni.com/discussions/220537?msg=1577860

Ronnie Lee Lamb I see your DNA is one of the two Y DNA attached to the Bach profiles.

After disconnections, there is ONE Y showing.
Tracking it down