(probably) Thomas Reeve - Updating the Reeve family of Long Island

Started by Erica Howton on Sunday, April 10, 2022
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Profiles Mentioned:

Showing all 5 posts

Feedback welcome.



Not the same as Robert Reeves


Biography

<The Reeves Project: A global genealogical collaboration> Reeve, Thomas. Last updated 14 April 2019.

Children of (probably) Thomas Reeve and wife of Thomas Reeve

Relationships of children are documented in various records of Southhold, Suffolk County, New York, i.e.

Probable child of unknown Reeve:

William Reeve was named as one of the executors of his brother James' estate in the 1692 will written by James Reeve and probated 4 Jul 1698.


Research Notes

< The Reeves Project: A global genealogical collaboration > Reeve, James (c1610 UK - bef 1671 NY)

Recently revisiting the research of this family in order to find the truth as to which Reeve individual, James or Thomas, was the husband of Mary Purrier, it became apparent that the James Reeve of the Osman Deposition could not have been the James Reeve of the 1692 Will since he would have to have been born circa 1610 and presumably his wife would have been close to that age therefore making it impossible for her to have been the mother of children born circa 1670 which the children named in that will would have been.

Discovery of the book The Refugees of 1776 from Long Island to Connecticut By Frederic Gregory Mather, Pub 1913, sheds more light on the family timeline although it does not solve the mystery instead raising the issue that the generations were mixed. The premise is suggested that James and Thomas were brothers and it was their [[(probably) Thomas Reeve (probably) Thomas Reeve] father] who was the husband of [[Mary Reeve Mary Reeve] Mary Purrier]. It suggests that it was the first Thomas who was the husband of Mary which still leaves the Osman Deposition's statement that it was James Reeve who was the son-in-law of William Purrier, but this timeline and view of the generations of the family makes more sense otherwise.

This published study based upon the depositions of Thomas Osman does not make any assertions regarding a familial relationship between James Reeve and Thomas Reeve who was also named in the deposition; however Y-DNA of descendants of both James and Thomas matches, proving that they were in some way related.


Although the father of James, William and Thomas Reeve of Long Island is generally believed to be unknown, if the published volume A history of Mattituck, Long Island, N.Y. is to be believed, their father was also named Thomas. That book on page 44 makes the statement “The eastern part of the Reeve lot was owned wholly or part by William Reeve who died in 1696 a son of 1st Thomas.”

References

(3) It seems Thomas had a daughter Hannah Reeve born 1657 (citation needed). The old NYGBR identified the 1st wife? of Peter Dickerson as “a daughter of the Thomas Reeve who died between 1675 & 1683.” < GoogleBooks > That describes his son Thomas Reeve, Jr. who however is too young to hace fathered Peter’s wife; nor is a name “Hannah” given. Later studies are skeptical that Peter Dickerson had a first wife at all. There does not seem to be a record for a daughter of either Thomas Reeve that fits the descriptions.

Private User Please review the tree.

Erica Howton thanks, looks good, as always!

Showing all 5 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion