Error on Profile of Robert I, King of Scots

Started by Charles Franklin Glisson III on Saturday, December 3, 2022
Problem with this page?

Participants:

Related Projects:

Showing all 20 posts

Fred Patton Jr. has an error on "Robert the 1st" King of Scots, profile.
He listed "Robert the 2nd" as the son of "Robert the 1st",
when in fact "Robert the 2nd", was "Robert the 1st's" GRANDSON.

"Robert the 1st's" daughter, "Marjorie" was "Robert the 1st's" daughter, and SHE was "Robert the 2nds" Mother.

I am Robert the 1st's 22nd Great Grandson

Anybody LISTENING in here?

Who is Fred Patton Jr and why does it interest anybody here if he has an error?

Without tagging any profiles a Discussion will get very few views.

Here are links to Robert II, King of Scots , Marjorie Bruce, Princess of Scotland and Robert I the Bruce, King of Scots

On Geni Robert II is grandson of Robert I.

Alex Moes,
Because when there is an error...it is not correct information. Now how hard was that to figure out? Some of you people are really rude. Maybe Charles is new. Give him a break. People like you are why i am not renewing my Geni pro.

Beverly Renee Hallman Marsh, Gedmatch Kit #XK9447597

I fully agree with you! In Europe we say: "C'est la ton qui fait la musique".

Beverly Renee Hallman Marsh, Gedmatch Kit #XK9447597 what is the error? What is the incorrect information?

On Geni Robert I is Marjorie's father and Marjorie is Robert II's mother, there is no error so trying to figure out Charles' comment is exactly what I am doing.

I don't appreciate your personal attack on me but as some in Eurpoe say "c'est la vie!'

...and Robert I is my 19th GGF...to put this in perspective... Each of us has 2,097,152 19th GGP. In the instance you speak of 22nd GGF...each of us has 16,777,216 22nd GGP....there is no discernable DNA at this stage. I'll willing to bet you are also related to Charlamagne. We are all cousins cousin!

Alex Moes,
You were rude, and you know it. And as we say here in the US...Bless your heart.

Robert II, King of Scots is my 9th cousin 14 times removed.
Robert I the Bruce, King of Scots is my 10th cousin 13 times removed.
Marjorie Bruce, Princess of Scotland is my 11th cousin 12 times remove

Hi famz! Robert I, The Bruce, King of the Scots is my 19th GGF. I see on his profile that Marjorie is his daughter and Robert II is her son, his grandson. Sorry, but not sure how to find the profile with the said error.

Robert II, King of Scots is my second cousin 20 times removed.

Robert I the Bruce, King of Scots is my 21st great uncle.

Marjorie Bruce, Princess of Scotland is my third cousin 18 times removed.

THIS one goes OUT to; "Alex Moses"

I found, an "Error" on a PROFILE of the "Bruce Monarchy" that I POLITELY brought to "Everyones Attention",
and
I don’t Appreciate the "Personal Attacks , FROM YOU!

The person who maintains the profile in question refuses to dialog with me, but HIS "Incorrect Info" efects EVERYONE to "Some Extent" when it is ALL "Said & Done" EVEN YOU "Alex"!

Robert the 1st, just HAPPENS to be MY DIRECT 23RD GREAT GRANDFATHER, and "Marjorie" just HAPPENS to be MY 22nd GREAT GRANDMOTHER not "Twice Removed" FROM ANYTHING!

Those are MY "Direct Relatives", and if YOU are UNWILLING to HELP with maintaining the INTEGRITY of the FACTS. then just maybe YOU should NOT BE PARTICIPATING on the "Family Trees" when the ACCURACY of "Said Trees" effects EVERYONE!

And in Closing, to "Alex Moses", i say;

"as SOME say in AMERICA,
Don't SERVE the sausage, if you CAN'T TAKE the sausage!"

Well, it would appear that Fred Patton Jr. did FINALLY "Fix" the error on HIS profile of MY 21st DIRECT 21th Great Grandfather; Robert 2nd,

He just never bothered to contact me with the acknowledgment, I guess he is some kind of "Recluse", and expects ME to CHECK on HIM, but I digress!

But I would like to Thank "Charles F. Glisson III" for his "Due Diligence" in his thankless efforts in finding an error and taking the proactive steps in getting the corrections made.

YOUR WELCOME!

Hey, and I didn’t "Do" any of those "Pesky Merges" EITHER!

Ahh so you meant this guy. James Fred Patin, Jr.

Thanks for the Bruce link. That helped alot. Cheers

Said profile has a few hundred managers so any one of them may have made an error and/or corrected it? Or only the curator?. I'm still learning my way aroind Geni myself.

You can see the history of a profile on the revisions tab.

I don’t see any recent merges on Robert ll or Robert l, and James Patin is not an active member since 2016. So I’m guessing that Charles Franklin Glisson III may have seen something, but whatever it was, it’s fixed?

Anyway, I’m glad for the attention called.

Charles Franklin Glisson III

If you relationship path was not showing a direct route between yourself and Robert I but instead an in-law path it is likely because a merge had taken place and the relationship calculation software needed a few days to catch up (it refreshes on a cyclical basis not constantly with every change). This is a common occurrence this high in the tree and is not an error or indeed a problem that needs correcting.

Thanks for the clarification Erica Howton . Cheers

Thank you Charles Franklin Glisson III for having such a sharp eye and your attention to detail. I am your distant cousin in America. A commoner from very humble beginnings. I follow Robert I and Robert II profiles and it is very important to me that the information is accurate. I want you to know you are very much appreciated as you don't get paid to do what you did.

I started not to say anything but since I "pay to say" how much I appreciate what you did for my 19th Great Grandfather. Imagine that. Hugs from Virginia USA

Robert II, King of Scots is your 19th great grandfather.
You
→ Vanessa Brooks YQ6082323
your mother → Mamie Lee Brooks (Williams)
her mother → Mamie Virginia
her mother → Nora Whitaker
her mother → Mary Jane Brooks
her mother → Thomas Baker Kerr
her father → William B. Kerr
his father → Nancy Kerr
his mother → Mary Margaret Mitchell
her mother → Janet McGowan
her mother → James Leckie
her father → John Leckie
his father → James Leckie of Leckie, Stirlingshire
his father → Euphemia Maxwell
his mother → Marion Cunningham
her mother → Giles Cunninghame
her mother → Marion Cunningham
her mother → Christian Lindsay
her mother → Alexander Lindsay, 2nd Earl of Crawford
her father → Elizabeth Stewart, Countess of Crawford
his mother → Robert II, King of Scots
her father

Showing all 20 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion