Proof of Mayflower Descent: Constance Doane, Proof of connection to Stephen Hopkins?

Problem with this page?

Profiles Mentioned:

Related Projects:

Showing all 4 posts

Curious why is Constance? Doane still connected to her parents when the bio acknowledges the Mayflower Society does not accept the line to Stephen Hopkins?

WikiTree has also cut the line, and has a good amount of info.

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Unknown-662675

https://archive.org/details/mayflower-quarterly-vol-86-no-3-fall-20... for more info from the Mayflower Society

The bio for Constance (Hopkins) Snow, "Mayflower" Passenger uses te language "may have been the mother" and is ambiguous. So, I am wondering why the relationship path is still connected?

Thank you!

Or clearly connection to Constance Hopkins. I used Stephen in hopes of a cleaner title. Either works! :-) It seems very messy...with no clear proof, and DNA testing (mtDNA)having only made things more unclear.

Thanks for calling attention and for the article. I've detached Daniel Doane's wife as a daughter of Nicholas Snow & Constance Hopkins & added the article as document as a citation.

To summarize:

"Does anyone know if GSMD [General Society of Mayflower Descendants} has budged re Constance (Snow) Doane?" < [https://www.wikitree.com/g2g/1673435/does-anyone-know-if-gsmd-has-b... Wikitree discussion] > "A couple of years ago, the GSMD tracked down matrilineal (all female line) descendants of Daniel Doane and his wife (said to be Constance Hopkins). They found and mtDNA tested two individuals. Neither one of them matched the known mtDNA signature of Constance (Hopkins) Snow, discovered by mtDNA testing matrilineal descendants of her other known daughters. Interestingly, the two individuals supposedly descended from Daniel Doane fell into different mtDNA haplogroups. Either one (or both) individuals' lines were wrong, or Daniel Doane was married more than once. In the end, this mtDNA testing likely puts the "final nail in the coffin" for Daniel to have married a daughter of Constance (Hopkins) Snow." (answered Dec 13, 2023)

My caveat would be that there does not yet seem to be a published study showing the full parameters, so we can evaluate the data for ourselves more transparently.

As of a year ago:

"I am a Mayflower Society State Historian, and according to the latest info I have from GSMD, this rejected connection (rejected in 1948) is still in place. The rejection statement is that Daniel Doane is not proven to be married to Constance, d/o Constance Hopkins and Nicholas Snow."

Thank you Erica.

There is also Anthony Snow although nothing exists to suggest a child named Constance with Abigail Warren, at least the possibility for other explanations for the Snow surname.

It would be nice to see the full study.

Showing all 4 posts

Create a free account or login to participate in this discussion